ISSN: 17535190
First published in 2008
3 issues per volume
Volume 1 Issue 2
Cover Date: June 2008
In the Café Flaubert
purchase PDF
Authors:  Mary Anne Francis 
DOI: 10.1386/jwcp.1.2.133_1

an artist's writing, situational fiction, conversational theory, image-text, Richard Rorty's pragmatism

Developing my long-held contention that an artist might write art-theory differently from non-artist theorists, this paper offers an instantiation of one possible approach. First and foremost, it proposes that an artist's art-theory might utilize their understanding of aesthetic form and functioning to conceive of writing as another ‘art-form’, now taking place in words and referencing the structures associated with that medium. With a nod to Plato's dialogues, the text adopts the format of a fictional conversation offered as reportage, which takes place between the artist-writer and a philosopher – an expert on the subject of ‘truth regimes’. The artist consults him in order to progress a project. What ensues puts the artist-writer's preference for a ‘realist’ approach to writing (representation as ‘reflection’) into play with the academic's overview of this and other ‘truth regimes’. Introduced to Richard Rorty's pragmatism and hence the idea of ‘truth’ as ‘use-value’, the artist is initially bewildered, only later realizing that it takes her project in a new direction. Given that the text's departure from the form of conventional art-theory is embodied (not just represented), the issues that it raises are implicit, but include: the (dis)advantages of fictional dialogue as ‘theory’. (On the one hand both the reader and the writer imaginatively inhabit different points of view more readily than happens with non-fictional prose. On the other hand, fictional dialogue may indulge unreliable spokespersons for particular theoretical positions.) Another point for debate concerns the recourse to the Renaissance pedagogic concept of ‘teaching through delight’. (While aesthetic pleasure-in-the-text is a spur for both the writer and the reader, the sensuous dimensions of dramatic embodiment may offer a distraction from more substantial issues.) As much as this text is an instance of ‘a writing-as-an-art-form as theory’, it also proposes, reciprocally, that ‘theory’ may be found outside non-fictional, non-aesthetic academic discourse. When this is the oblique logic of the writing's form, it is also explicitly elaborated in the article, as Dürer's woodcut The Draughtsman and the Lute is seen to comprise observations about the conditions of representation that re-appear in the ‘picture’ that is the fictional discussion in the Café Flaubert.
Your tags: Please login or register if you don't have a user account.
Latest news
13th March 2018
Choreographies by Jacky Lansley
Read more Read more
5th March 2018
BAFTSS 6th Annual Conference 2018 - University of Kent 12-13 April
Read more Read more
5th March 2018
Sotheby's Prize: Now accepting applications
Read more Read more


The Big Picture Magazine